34 Garfield Place is a four-condo conversion on a 25-foot-wide, 115-foot-deep lot on Garfield Place between 4th and 5th Avenues in Park Slope. Every home has private outdoor space, and all four have closed, about four months after the first one listed.
Where Things Stand
All four homes at 34 Garfield Place have closed as of November 1, 2026. The Attorney General accepted the offering plan on October 16, 2025. The penthouse listed first, on November 26, 2025, and went into contract a week later; the last contract was signed on March 20, 2026. That's about four months from first listing to last contract. Across the five other Brooklyn projects of 2 to 6 homes I've tracked to a sellout, the typical one took about three months, so the building as a whole sold at close to the usual pace, but each home went into contract within about a week of hitting the market, and the garden duplex went into contract the day it first listed. The developer is Habitat Living NYC, the same team behind 42 and 44 Garfield Place. Want to see upcoming projects by this sponsor? Reach out below.
Homes here will now come up only as resales. Join my early access list below and you'll hear when one does, or when a similar building launches nearby, before it reaches StreetEasy.
The Numbers So Far
As of November 1, 2026, from recorded sales:
Total sellout: about $12.96 million across four homes
Penthouse (Residence 4): a four-bedroom, three-bath duplex of about 1,747 square feet with two terraces and private elevator access, sold for $3,317,438 (last asking $3,250,000)
Residence 2: a three-bedroom, two-bath home of about 1,451 square feet with a private rear terrace, sold for $2,851,100 (last asking $2,695,000)
Residence 3: a three-bedroom, two-bath home of about 1,340 square feet with a private rear terrace, sold for $2,642,359 (last asking $2,595,000)
Garden duplex: three bedrooms, two full baths and two powder rooms across about 3,718 square feet, including the lower level, with a private garden, sold for $4,150,000 (first listed at $4,500,000)
Average price per square foot: about $1,740. The three upper homes sold for about $1,900 to $1,970 a foot; the garden duplex works out lower because its size includes the lower level
Monthly costs: common charges plus taxes of about $944 to $2,056
Time to sell out: about four months from first listing to last contract
Compared with other new development in Park Slope: about $1,740 per square foot here, against about $1,941 at 132 Sixth Avenue, $1,736 at 511 8th Avenue and $1,449 at 270 14th Street
Example sales: Residence 2, a three-bedroom with a terrace, sold for $2,851,100, and the four-bedroom penthouse duplex sold for $3,317,438.
Buying in a New Development?
New construction works differently than a resale: offering plans, sponsor contracts, closing costs and timelines all have their own rules.
A Closer Look at the Building
The conversion created four large homes, each with private outdoor space: a garden duplex with a glass atrium that pulls light down to the lower level, two three-bedroom floor-throughs with rear terraces, and a four-bedroom penthouse duplex with two terraces and its own private elevator, which the penthouse owner maintains. Finishes include wide-plank solid white oak floors, custom natural oak Shinnoki kitchens with Carrara marble counters, integrated Fisher & Paykel appliances, a dedicated laundry room off each kitchen, radiant heated floors in the primary baths and lighting from In Common With and Rich Brilliant Willing. Apart from the penthouse elevator, it's a walk-up.
Park Slope Highlights
Living at 34 Garfield Place means having JJ Byrne Playground just two blocks away. You're also close to the Whole Foods on 3rd Avenue and everything cropping up along Gowanus. Between Brooklyn Ninja Academy, Gotham Gymnastics and Goldfish Swim School, my family is there almost every weekend. 5th Avenue is a dining hub with summer open streets, and the Halloween parade ends practically on your doorstep.
The R at Union Street, about a 4-minute walk
The F, G and R at 4th Avenue and 9th Street, about 12 minutes on foot
The 2 and 3 at Grand Army Plaza and the B and Q at 7th Avenue, about 13 to 14 minutes
Prospect Park, about a 15-minute walk up the Slope
Katie's Take
I track every new development in Brooklyn, and here's how this one compares: 34 Garfield Place priced right in line with the other new Park Slope condos I follow, and every home went into contract within about a week of listing, which tells me buyers here are waiting for three- and four-bedroom homes with outdoor space and move fast when one appears. The biggest home, the garden duplex, went into contract before most people saw it. If that's the home you want in Park Slope, have your financing ready before the next one lists; 511 8th Avenue and 132 Sixth Avenue are selling now.
Want to talk through what's coming up nearby? Let's talk.